U.S. Rebel s Split Riles $6 Billion World of Ethical Commerce
JOIN OUR MAILING LIST
Enter Email
CONTRIBUTE TODAY
FOLLOW US ON
FEATURED CAMPAIGN

 Watch the Video

FacebookTwitterGoogle+EmailShare

Simon Clark

November 2, 2011

 

Fairtrade International brings together retailers and other marketers in wealthy countries with small-scale producers of foods in the developing world. The organization’s goal is to ensure the ethical treatment of workers. Retailers in the U.S., Europe and elsewhere can then sell these products as Fairtrade-labeled.

Small farmers find affluent customers, who reap the satisfaction of knowing their purchases are helping a person, not an enormous, faceless agro-corporation. Last year $6 billion worth of Fairtrade-approved goods were sold globally, up 27 percent from 2009.

There’s trouble in this utopia, though. Fair Trade USA, the largest American group, announced on Sept. 15 that it would split from Bonn-based Fairtrade International, which coordinates groups worldwide and imposes the standards that make fair trade such a powerful force. Fair Trade USA has started a separate label that retailers can use to boost sales of coffee, chocolate and fruits around the globe.

That’s sparked an uproar as fair-trade advocates claim Fair Trade USA Chief Executive Paul Rice is putting standards at risk just to boost sales, Bloomberg Businessweek reports in its Nov. 7 issue.

“Lowered standards undermine the fair-trade values producers, activists and consumers have advocated,” said Maria Louzon, national coordinator of United Students for Fair Trade. She vowed to boycott goods bearing the Fair Trade USA logo, including popular Green Mountain Coffee.

Getting Results

Rice rejects the assertion that he’s damaging fair-trade standards. “We are after results,” he said. “We want to get things done.”

Fairtrade International CEO Rob Cameron has been more restrained in his response than groups such as United Students for Fair Trade. Cameron wrote in an open letter on Sept. 16 that he and his colleagues “sincerely regret” Fair Trade USA’s decision.

Some of this may be attributed to growing pains as the labeling movement, which started more than 20 years ago, expands.

“Fair trade has caught the interest of big businesses, and that makes it possible to move large volumes of product,” said Jonathan Rosenthal, a pioneer in the movement and co-founder of the Massachusetts-based cooperative Equal Exchange. “The risk is that fair-trade standards fall to the lowest common denominator,” said Rosenthal, who supports the original vision for fair trade.

Rice is breaking away after 13 years because he said it will be easier to make business-friendly decisions and double U.S. fair-trade sales by 2015.

Connecting to Consumers

“Historically, so many folks in the movement saw fair trade as a partnership between producers in the developing world and consumers in the global north,” Rice said in an Oct. 12 conference call with fair-trade advocates. “Companies were kind of a necessary evil to make that partnership possible.”

He sees the capitalist appetite for more fair-trade products as something to encourage. “Competition is not a bad thing,” said Rice, who earned an MBA at the University of California at Berkeley after founding a coffee cooperative in Nicaragua. “Companies like Wal-Mart, Costco, Green Mountain, Starbucks and Ben & Jerry’s are expanding their offerings in terms of fair-trade products.”

Rice would like to award the fair-trade label to coffee grown on larger estates: At present, only small-scale coffee farms qualify under Fairtrade International standards, though it does certify other products grown on estates such as bananas. Rice is also testing fair-trade certification for cotton clothing even though the Bonn organization doesn’t certify apparel yet.

Ben & Jerry’s Pledge

Fair Trade USA got a commitment from Ben & Jerry’s to use non-fair-trade ingredients only if their fair-trade equivalents weren’t available by 2013. A spokeswoman for the ice cream company said, however, that the pledge may be implemented “a little later.”

Rice’s moves are straining his relations with fair-trade organizations. Portland, Oregon-based Fair World Project, which campaigns for transparent fair-trade and organic standards, said Fair Trade USA is going “rogue.”

In another controversial decision, Rice has allowed use of the Fair Trade USA label on chocolate bars with approved cocoa even if the sugar in them isn’t fair trade. “We decided to not sacrifice the livelihoods of cocoa farmers on the altar of some misguided principle,” Rice said in the Oct. 12 conference call. “We decided to be flexible.”

Flexibility looks like hypocrisy to the purists. Said Luzon: “It is unacceptable that a company be allowed to produce a fair-trade chocolate bar with non-fair-trade sugar when such sugar is available.”

To contact the reporter on this story: Simon Clark in London at sclark4@bloomberg.net

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Melissa Pozsgay in Paris at mpozsgay@bloomberg.net

FacebookTwitterGoogle+EmailShare

Truly Equitable Trade: A Vision for Transformative Markets

credit - Equal Exchange Coop - Cooperativa Norandino Members

Fair trade has shown itself to be a successful model for building capacity and allowing marginalized producers to enter the market. Yet the fair trade movement is falling short of its potential to achieve genuine, profound, inclusive and democratic fair trade that truly transforms the way in which markets and economies are established. In June […]

The Road to Food Sovereignty

Global Land Use and Food Production Statistics

For every dollar consumers spent in supermarkets, health and environmental damages cost two dollars more. Our planet can no longer afford the industrial food chain that is destroying our planet and our health. The solution? To support the interlinked network of small-scale farmers, livestock-keepers, pastoralists, hunters and gatherers, fishers and urban producers who already feed […]

Fair For All: The Climate Solutions Embedded in Fair Trade

Woman picks Papaya - Serendipol - Dr Bronner

Experts agree, it’s high time we make some changes in the ways we grow food and crops. The good news is that small scale-farmers and their fair trade cooperatives are already leading the way to a new future—read on for seven principles that fair trade and climate advocates can agree on. Written by Anna Canning […]

Collaborating to Cool the Planet

photo-credit: Coop Coffees - Training group

How Farmer-to-Farmer Trainings Are Spreading New Solutions to Climate Change In the fall of 2017, Grow Ahead, a partner of Fair World Project, successfully crowdfunded a farmer-to-farmer training in Nicaragua. Here’s what José Fernando Reyes of Norandino Cooperative in Peru has to say about his experience. How Farmer-to-Farmer Trainings are Spreading New Solutions to Climate […]

Building Power From the Ground Up

Black Dirt Farm Collective

“There is no food sovereignty without land; land really is the basis of power, and it does not get simpler than that. Land is the primary mechanism for many of us poor folks and people of color to actually have something to stand on and have a future to farm. And it is not just […]

Product Picks

Tortilla Stones

We asked members of our staff and editorial board for some of their current favorite products that support traditional foods and the communities they are rooted in. Find them online or at your favorite natural food store! Deforestation, decreasing biodiversity, increasing pesticide use – those are just a few of the ways that our industrial […]

Fair Trade is the Pathway to Regenerative Agriculture

Coop Coffee

The movement for a food system that sustains people and planet is been growing. Fair trade offers a model to incorporate fair livelihoods and the true cost of production into regenerative agriculture models that are both new and very old, feeding the world and tending the planet. Written by Ryan Zinn The climate is changing, […]

A Soil-to-Soil Vision for the Fashion Revolution

Paige Green - Fibershed

From origins in Northern California, Fibershed is building a global network of regional regenerative fiber systems. Founder Rebecca Burgess describes her vision for vibrant local fibersheds that connect us to the landscapes that grow what we wear and sustains a new generation of farmers, ranchers, natural dyers and mills. From conventional cotton production, which uses […]

Fair Trade As We Do It: the Story of Jumbo Nuts

Annie Jose sewing rice seeds into her rice paddy

Fair Trade Alliance Kerala, the small-farmer collective I work for, is recapturing the homestead farming traditions of Kerala. Our goal is to grow to about 10,000 farming families stewarding about 40,000 acres of farmland, creating conditions that are akin to a tropical rainforest in crop diversity and biodiversity. For us, biodiversity is a food security […]

Regenetarians Unite!

Regenetarians Unite

As eaters, we have a choice: will our diets restore and replenish the earth, or will they deplete it? An exploration of three key principles that look beyond simple distinctions between omnivore and vegan towards a new Regenetarian ethos. By David Bronner How the Regenerative Agriculture and Animal Welfare Movements Can End Factory Farming, Restore […]