The Toughest Fair Trade Nut to Crack
Enter Email

 Watch the Video


John Bowes

September 1, 2011


Sales of fair trade products in the United States have been booming.  According to the Fair Trade Labelling Organizations International  (FLO), they amounted to $1.2 billion last year – quadruple the figure in 2004. This is a truly staggering rate of growth.

Fair trade practices grew out of the concerns of a small number of activists for poverty-stricken farmers in the global south. These pioneers sought to assure that producers would be given better market access and fair prices for their goods. As important and well-intentioned as these people were, a fundamental sea change was required for their products to have a material impact on the marketplace.

Max Havelaar, a Dutch-Christian development agency, introduced the first fair trade label. They paid producers a fair price for their crops and issued independent certification allowing the goods to be sold to supermarkets for the first time. This idea was replicated across Europe and North America, and its success led to the establishment of FLO in 1997. In the U.S., Transfair is the formal labelling authority and it has embarked on a drive to bring fair trade benefits to millions in the developing world. Today, the United Kingdom is the only nation on Earth with a bigger market than the U.S. for fair trade products.

But let’s offer a little perspective. The United States has a population in excess of 300 million people. It is one of the biggest nations in the world. You don’t need a post grad in math to recognize that its per capita consumption of fair trade products is less than a fifth of that in the U.K. — a country with just 62 million people. Of all the nations in the northern hemisphere recorded by FLO, only Italy, Spain, Estonia and the Czech Republic have a lower rate of fair trade per capita consumption than the U.S.

Why is Fair Trade doing so badly in America?

It has been argued that the culture’s self-centered political and emotional isolationism is the culprit, banded together with its commitment to a capitalist market economy, one which drives the pursuit of personal wealth at the expense of an empathetic response to global economic and social problems.

This kind of thinking is given superficial credence by Americans’ apparent reluctance to visit different places and experience different cultures. Almost 50 million Brits have passports; about 83 percent of the population. So we are astonished to read that only 21 percent  of U.S. citizens possess a passport. Does this lack of exposure to foreign peoples lend itself to a culture of isolationism?

Perhaps, but any contention that Americans lack heart is belied by their record on charitable donations; giving represents about 1.7 percent of gross domestic product; about twice the level of Canada and the U.K.

Perhaps the fundamental problem is leadership. In the U.K., the Fairtrade Foundation provides determined and focused leadership for the whole fair trade sector. In the U.S., by contrast, Transfair appears to be at almost constant loggerheads with the alternative trading organizations who were the original pioneers of the movement.

The internal debate is split into the transformer view, associated with the alternative trading organizations, and the reformer view, associated with Transfair. The former group wants to transform the trading system by creating holistic partnerships linking the small farmer to the consumer. The reformers have a more incremental approach and seek to operate within established trading frameworks; they have happily concluded deals with multinational companies such as Starbucks and Dole, entities which many in the fair trade movement associate with just the abuses their current efforts are designed to address.

These concerns are shared by many in the U.K. When Nestle, the bette noir of the U.K. ethical movement, incorporated the Fairtrade mark on its Partners Blend coffee, plenty of dissenting voices saw it as a grotesque act of cynicism. But in the U.K. the emphasis has been on partnership and co-operation. As a result the movement has been able to offer a consistent and coordinated message. The Fairtrade mark is now almost ubiquitous, and recognized by more than 70 percent of British adults. Retail sales have passed the 1-billion pound ($1.6 billion) mark.

Now it’s time for the U.S. to flex its fair trade muscle. Success in the largest consumer market on Earth is essential to change inequitable global trading practices. Fair trade has come a long way in a relatively short period, but its progress is still embryonic. Of all of the challenges it faces going forward, the United States is the toughest nut to crack.

John Bowes is editor of the recently released book The Fair Trade Revolution and chairman of Twin, a pioneering producer-owned membership organization dedicated to developing fair trade supply chains for coffee, nuts, cocoa, and sugar. He previously worked for the Co-operative Group, one of the top five U.K. retailers, where he was responsible for many of their ground-breaking initiatives on fair trade.


Fair Cities


    What will the just economy of the future look like? We asked for your suggestions for cities across North America that are living examples of fair trade values in action. Is yours on the list? MINNEAPOLIS/ST PAUL, Minnesota Minneapolis-St. Paul is a hotbed of fair trade activity. For decades now, local nonprofits like the […]

It’s Time for Wages With Dignity


by Ryan Johnson Quietly, hidden behind the headlines that feature presidential candidates bemoaning the state of our country and our economy, voters in several states are no longer waiting on politicians. They’re taking matters into their own hands and launching minimum wage ballot initiatives to create the economic change people sorely need. The impetus for […]

The Business Case for Raising the Minimum Wage


by David Bronner At Dr. Bronner’s, the company I run with my family, we believe that we can only prosper in the long run if we contribute to the prosperity of society as a whole. It’s why we strive to compensate all our staff fairly, cap executive compensation at five times the lowest paid position, […]

“Berta Did Not Die. She Multiplied.”


A Tribute to the Work of Berta Cáceres, Indigenous Rights Leader by Ryan Zinn Berta Cáceres was murdered in her home on March 3, 2016 in the community of La Esperanza, Honduras. Berta cofounded the Civic Council of Popular and Indigenous Organizations of Honduras (COPINH) in 1993, a grassroots organization that struggled for indigenous rights […]

Lucky – A Guest Worker’s Story


By David Mohrmann Though he had not wanted to leave his wife and children for six months, had not wanted to sleep on a cot in a room with three other men, had not wanted to work long days under difficult conditions, Miguel said he was one of the lucky ones. At least he had […]

Fair Chance Employment Benefits Us All


By Terrell Hall Earning a living wage through gainful employment is crucial to the huge number of Americans struggling to make ends meet, including the 630,000 women and men who will come home from prison this year. A staggering amount of employment challenges await the formerly incarcerated because of their felony convictions. Particularly hard hit […]

Policy Corner: Farms in California Prepare for $15/Hour Minimum Wage


By Kerstin Lindgren California legislators, responding to the growing Fight for $15 and Raise the Wage movements, passed a law earlier this year that will guarantee all workers in the state a minimum wage of $15 an hour. This is great news for farmworkers in the country’s largest agricultural state. But will it be a […]

From Weaving to Seed-Saving, Climate Change, and Fighting Monsanto


A Guatemalan Woman’s Story of Empowerment Through Organizing an interview with Yolanda Sebastiana Calgua Morales Working together in cooperatives is an empowering aspect of the fair trade movement for farmers and artisans around the world. On a recent trip to Guatemala, Dana Geffner, Executive Director of Fair World Project, sat down with Yolanda Sebastiana Calgua […]

Radio CATA


A Radio Station to Empower the Latino Community By Meghan Hurley In November of 2015, CATA, The Farmworkers Support Committee, officially launched Radio CATA, its own Spanish language non-commercial low-power FM radio station in Bridgeton, New Jersey. The radio station began as a way to reach out to the immigrant community and engage them in […]

Small is Beautiful: But Can Its Rules be Applied to the Fashion Industry?


Contributing writer, Safia Minney, Founder and Director of People Tree, argues that we must make and buy clothes while being conscious of their humanity and sustainability. People Tree is working with small-scale organic farmer, artisan and tailor fair trade groups in eight countries. This year is People Tree’s 25th anniversary in Japan where I started […]