Fair World Project Letter to Paul Rice
Enter Email

 Watch the Video


November 15, 2011



Dear Paul,


Thank you for responding to Fair World Project’s (FWP) letter and concerns regarding Fair Trade USA’s (FTUSA) labeling and commercial availability standards. I’ve read with great interest that FTUSA is reconsidering its labeling standards and is actively engaging stakeholders on this issue.   FWP commends FTUSA’s work to expand the fair trade market.  However, as a FLO member, FTUSA unilaterally chose to ignore the FLO commercially availability requirement for multi-ingredient products which states that ““all that can be certified fair trade must be fair trade.”


FTUSA has made it clear on several occasions, including during public webinars and in the media, that the new FTUSA’s standards will not include a fair trade commercial availability requirement. Fair World Project’s concerns with this approach to multi-ingredient fair trade products are twofold: 1) the unilateral process by which this decision was made within FTUSA and 2) the implications of not establishing an enforceable commercial availability standard for multi-ingredient fair trade products.





  1. While FWP is encouraged by FTUSA’s willingness to revisit its  labeling standards and is consulting stakeholders, FWP wishes to underscore that this process must be transparent and documented, with FTUSA accountable to the larger fair trade movement and market.   Specifically, FTUSA should create an online portal for this issue, similar to the portal for “Farm Workers Standard”  (http://fairtradeusa.org/certification/standards), with a reasonable timeline for compiling and reviewing stakeholder input.   
  2. A strong and enforced fair trade commercial availability standard, analogous to FLO 2.2 or IMO 1.1.1, is critical to assure that conventional companies with little long-term investment to fair trade establish fair trade supply chains and expand the impact for producers. Without a commercial availability requirement, manufacturers have little incentive to source fair trade ingredients beyond the bare minimum to receive the FTC mark. Claiming that you will “strongly encourage” a company out of producing a product that sources only Fair Trade Certified sugar and no Fair Trade Chocolate (or other ingredients that are widely commercially available) is not sufficient. This case was stated on a FTUSA webinar with a Hot Cocoa product.  This standard must have clear and enforceable guidelines.
  3. As written, FTUSA’s labeling requirements technically allow for multi-ingredient products to carry the “Fair Trade Certified” mark so long as they reach a minimum dry weight of 25% fair trade ingredients. Without a fair trade commercial availability requirement, manufactures will be granted use of the FTC mark for multi-ingredient products with only 25% FTC content, even if their product could contain a higher percentage of FTC content.
  4. FTUSA does not have a public policy for granting exceptions or for manufacturers transitioning their supply chain to fair trade. If exceptions are granted, clear benchmarks for increasing their fair trade ingredient thresholds must be made public and within 18 months they must start to use the commercially available fair trade ingredients.    
  5. As currently written, FTUSA labeling policies do not allow for manufacturers and consumers to easily distinguish products with high Fair Trade content and those with minimal fair trade content. Dedicated fair trade manufacturers that source 100% of Fair Trade ingredients will be at an unfair advantage when consumers must chose between similar products, one with a maximum percentage of Fair Trade ingredient, and one with only the minimum. . To assure a level playing field for consumers and manufacturers labeling requirements must include a clear identifier for the percentage of Fair Trade ingredients.  Ingredients logo must be accompanied by a % of fair trade ingredients if used on the front panel.


 Thank you for your time and consideration. I await your response.  In the ongoing process of transparency we will post this and other correspondence on our website. 




Dana Geffner

Executive Director

Fair World Project



Fair Cities


    What will the just economy of the future look like? We asked for your suggestions for cities across North America that are living examples of fair trade values in action. Is yours on the list? MINNEAPOLIS/ST PAUL, Minnesota Minneapolis-St. Paul is a hotbed of fair trade activity. For decades now, local nonprofits like the […]

It’s Time for Wages With Dignity


by Ryan Johnson Quietly, hidden behind the headlines that feature presidential candidates bemoaning the state of our country and our economy, voters in several states are no longer waiting on politicians. They’re taking matters into their own hands and launching minimum wage ballot initiatives to create the economic change people sorely need. The impetus for […]

The Business Case for Raising the Minimum Wage


by David Bronner At Dr. Bronner’s, the company I run with my family, we believe that we can only prosper in the long run if we contribute to the prosperity of society as a whole. It’s why we strive to compensate all our staff fairly, cap executive compensation at five times the lowest paid position, […]

“Berta Did Not Die. She Multiplied.”


A Tribute to the Work of Berta Cáceres, Indigenous Rights Leader by Ryan Zinn Berta Cáceres was murdered in her home on March 3, 2016 in the community of La Esperanza, Honduras. Berta cofounded the Civic Council of Popular and Indigenous Organizations of Honduras (COPINH) in 1993, a grassroots organization that struggled for indigenous rights […]

Lucky – A Guest Worker’s Story


By David Mohrmann Though he had not wanted to leave his wife and children for six months, had not wanted to sleep on a cot in a room with three other men, had not wanted to work long days under difficult conditions, Miguel said he was one of the lucky ones. At least he had […]

Fair Chance Employment Benefits Us All


By Terrell Hall Earning a living wage through gainful employment is crucial to the huge number of Americans struggling to make ends meet, including the 630,000 women and men who will come home from prison this year. A staggering amount of employment challenges await the formerly incarcerated because of their felony convictions. Particularly hard hit […]

Policy Corner: Farms in California Prepare for $15/Hour Minimum Wage


By Kerstin Lindgren California legislators, responding to the growing Fight for $15 and Raise the Wage movements, passed a law earlier this year that will guarantee all workers in the state a minimum wage of $15 an hour. This is great news for farmworkers in the country’s largest agricultural state. But will it be a […]

From Weaving to Seed-Saving, Climate Change, and Fighting Monsanto


A Guatemalan Woman’s Story of Empowerment Through Organizing an interview with Yolanda Sebastiana Calgua Morales Working together in cooperatives is an empowering aspect of the fair trade movement for farmers and artisans around the world. On a recent trip to Guatemala, Dana Geffner, Executive Director of Fair World Project, sat down with Yolanda Sebastiana Calgua […]

Radio CATA


A Radio Station to Empower the Latino Community By Meghan Hurley In November of 2015, CATA, The Farmworkers Support Committee, officially launched Radio CATA, its own Spanish language non-commercial low-power FM radio station in Bridgeton, New Jersey. The radio station began as a way to reach out to the immigrant community and engage them in […]

Small is Beautiful: But Can Its Rules be Applied to the Fashion Industry?


Contributing writer, Safia Minney, Founder and Director of People Tree, argues that we must make and buy clothes while being conscious of their humanity and sustainability. People Tree is working with small-scale organic farmer, artisan and tailor fair trade groups in eight countries. This year is People Tree’s 25th anniversary in Japan where I started […]